SEO tracking means watching a short list of numbers that show whether people find your website in search and then do something once they arrive. For a small B2B or trades company, track five things: impressions and clicks by search phrase, which pages earn those clicks, calls and form fills from organic visitors, and whether AI assistants cite your pages. Two free Google tools and one free Microsoft tool cover all of it. Most of what else shows up on an SEO dashboard is decoration.
The five numbers, and where each one lives
| What to track | Where to find it | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Impressions by search phrase | Google Search Console, Performance report, Queries tab | Which searches Google shows you for, and whether that list is growing |
| Clicks and click-through rate | Search Console, same report | Whether people choose you once they see you |
| Top pages | Search Console, Pages tab | Which pages do the work, and which ones Google ignores |
| Calls and form fills from search | Google Analytics 4, key events filtered to organic traffic | Whether search visitors become inquiries |
| AI citations | Bing Webmaster Tools, AI Performance | How often Copilot and Bing's AI answers cite your pages |
Search Console: the starting point
Search Console is free, and it's the only place Google tells you directly how your site performs in its results. The Performance report defines its four core numbers plainly: clicks are the times someone clicked through to your site, impressions are how many times your site appeared, click-through rate is clicks divided by impressions, and average position is the average position of your topmost result.
Average position deserves a warning. It blends every search you showed up for, including odd ones on page eight, so it can drop while your business improves. Look at it phrase by phrase. Ignore it as a single number.
AI answers are folded into the same report. Google's page on AI features and your website says sites appearing in AI Overviews and AI Mode are included in the overall search traffic in Search Console, under the Web search type. There's no separate AI tab.
Analytics: where visitors turn into inquiries
Search Console stops at the click. To see what happens next you need Google Analytics 4, and specifically key events. Google defines a key event as an action that's particularly important to the success of your business. For most companies reading this, that's three things: a contact form sent, a quote request, and a tap on the phone number.
The phone tap is the one most often missing. Many B2B and trades buyers call. If your analytics only counts form fills, your reports undercount search, sometimes by a lot, and SEO looks weaker than it is. Ask whoever manages your site to mark a click on any phone link as a key event, then filter the report to organic search traffic.
AI citations: the newest number
Microsoft now reports how often its AI answers cite you. AI Performance in Bing Webmaster Tools, released as a public preview, shows total citations across Microsoft Copilot, AI-generated summaries in Bing and select partner integrations, plus which of your pages are cited and the phrases the AI used when it pulled them. Bing notes that the data is a sample of overall citation activity. Treat the trend as useful and the exact count as rough.
It doesn't cover ChatGPT, Google's AI or the other assistants. For a quick read on those, our Free AI Visibility Check looks at your website, your mobile speed, whether you come up in a local search, and what an AI assistant says when a buyer asks who to call. No email needed.
Numbers that look good and mean little
A ranking for a phrase nobody searches. Agencies sometimes report position one for a long, oddly specific phrase. Check the impressions next to it. If they're near zero, so is the value.
Total traffic. A blog post that goes mildly viral with students or job seekers can double your sessions and add nothing to your work. Filter to the pages that match what you sell.
Domain scores from third-party tools. They're estimates built by each tool's maker, and two tools will give the same site two different scores.
A monthly check that takes twenty minutes
Open Search Console and compare the last three months with the three before. Note the five phrases that gained the most impressions. Check the pages tab for anything that dropped sharply. Open Analytics and count calls and forms from organic search. Glance at Bing's AI Performance. Write three lines on what changed and what you'll do about it.
That's enough. A tracking program that someone actually reads beats a 30-page report nobody opens.
If you'd like someone else to watch the numbers
Every Inbound SDR client gets a dedicated strategist and a monthly report, along with the work the report measures: a website of up to 100 pages built in the first month, a new blog every business day posted to up to 3 social platforms, Google Business Profile and Bing Places optimization, directory consistency across 65 or more listings, and technical SEO with AI search crawlers allowed. Packages start at $1,000 per month on a 12-month term. We won't promise a ranking or a number of leads, and we'll tell you what the numbers show either way.
If you already have someone who reads Search Console every month and acts on it, you may only need the checklist above.
Get the next one in your inbox
New playbooks, benchmarks and guides from our sales floor, for owners and sales leaders who sell to businesses. One email a month. See past issues.
